Three Brothers Pizza

Reviews

• Måx Goldsmith

  star star star_border star_border star_border 3 June 2026

  Good food. But watch your money. I could tell the guy at the register seemed below board. So I asked for a receipt. Sure enough he overcharged me $4.00 and told me it was tax. Then the witch that runs the place tried to tell me it was tax too. Upon refusing to be silenced and doing 3rd grade math together, I was refunded the overcharge. The seedy dude apologized, the witch didn’t.

• Gregory MacDonald

  star star star star star 1 June 2026

  I'm from South of ye old Mason-Dixon so take that into account...but this is the best pizza I've had so far up here. Quality ingredients, perfect sauce, topping proportions, and the crust left me speechless. So thin, just crispy enough. Incredible.

• Andrew Trachtman

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  Giant, flavorful slices with a nice thin crust that has some nice crunch with an ever so slight chewiness makes the brothers a 5/5 for me. Slices are about $5 each, but they're huge and take up 2 plates. It's cool to see the pizzas being tossed fresh as well. Their indoor seating is great, but can fill up quickly. I hear they charge for cups of water. It seems like that's the "policy", but the staff are good people. Just get to know them and you'll get water for free (in cups with ice, not the bottles). Also, if you can eat an entire pie in under 13 minutes, you win 250 pies.

• Carrie Ciarlello

  star star star star star 26 May 2026

  Best Pizza on the Ocean City Boardwalk! We have had several different flavors but the family favorite is BBQ Chicken. The crust is great, all the ingredients are fresh and balanced perfectly. The chicken is real chicken. Accidentally ordered from Big Slice also on the OC Boardwalk during our last trip. A quick search for large pizza on the boardwalk while in route pretty much ruined our night. Horrible pizza. Thin burnt crust hardly any chicken or bbq and absolutely no cheese. Avoid Big Slice and go to Three Brothers! Three Brothers is awesome and gigantic to boot.

• Ellen M. Cohen

  star star star star star_border 19 May 2026

  Really great pizza. Right amount of everything, including the drip! Was there last summer and cannot wait to return this summer. Living in Tampa, but from NYC. I'm very particular about my pizza; there's only one place I'll eat pizza here unless I'm making it myself. Which we do often. Having said that, there are even some NYC places that I avoid, but when I'm north and head to the Shore, I've gotta make this place a stop! YUMMY